

Paris Saint-Germain: An International and Ethnic Profile–Part 1
By: Thomas | August 19th, 2009
In this post I’m going to be talking about where the squad comes from, analyzing this data, and drawing conclusions (that will most likely be utterly untrue) about it. First of all, I’m going to list the birthplace and nationality of all the members of our squad:
1. Grégory Coupet: Le Puy-en-Velay, France–French*.
2. Ceará: Crato, Brazil–Brazilian.
3. Mamadou Sakho: Paris, France–French.
4. Claude Makélélé: Kinshasa, DR Congo–French*.
6. Grégory Bourillon: Laval, France–French.
7. Ludovic Giuly: Lyon, France–French*.
8. Péguy Luyindula: Kinshasa, DR Congo–French*.
9. Guillaume Hoarau: Reunion, France–French.
10. Stéphane Sessegnon: Allahe, Benin–Beninese*.
11. Mevlüt Erdinç: Besancon, France–Turkish*.
12. Albert Baning: Douala, Cameroon–Cameroonian.
13. Sammy Traoré: Paris, France–Malian*.
14. Mateja Kezman: Zemun, Serbia–Serbian*.
15. Zoumana Camara: Paris, France–French*.
16. Willy Grondin: Reunion, France–French.
17. Granddi Ngoyi: Paris, France–Congolese French.
18. Loris Arnaud: Paris, France–French.
20. Clément Chantôme: Sens, France–French.
22. Sylvain Armand: Saint-Etienne, France–French.
23. Jérémy Clément: Montpellier, France–French.
24. Tripy Makonda: Paris, France–French.
25. Jerome Rothen: Paris, France–French*.
26. Christophe Jallet: Cognac, France–French.
27. Younousse Sankharé: Paris, France–French.
28. Maxime Partouche: Paris, France–French.
29. Yannick Boli: Paris, France–Ivorian.
30. Apoula Edel: Ekom I-Mfou, Cameroon–Armenian*.
*indicates international appearances for team indicated by nationality, not birthplace.
bold italics indicates that the player was born in France but plays for a different national team.
italics indicates the player plays for a different national team than that of their birth country.
bold indicates the player was born elsewhere but plays for the French National Team.
First of all, we have the list of players who were born and raised in Paris.
3. Mamadou Sakho: Paris, France–French.
13. Sammy Traoré: Paris, France–Malian*.
15. Zoumana Camara: Paris, France–French*.
17. Granddi Ngoyi: Paris, France–Congolese.
18. Loris Arnaud: Paris, France–French.
24. Tripy Makonda: Paris, France–French.
25. Jerome Rothen: Paris, France–French*.
27. Younousse Sankharé: Paris, France–French.
28. Maxime Partouche: Paris, France–French.
29. Yannick Boli: Paris, France–Ivorian.
Thats 10, If you didn’t bother to count, out of a squad of 27. That means a little over a third of the squad is from the city, an extremely high number (For reference, 1 player in the 30 player OL squad is from Lyon, and while doing this research, I found out that the Old Guardien (Coupet) is from the same tiny town as Govou!). There are several possible reasons for the unusually large number of native Parisians in the squad. The first of which is that the academy recruits almost exclusively from Paris, so players graduating the academy are a huge Parisian supply for the squad. Another is that since Paris is the largest city on the Old Continent (excepting Moscow, which may or may not be in Europe), there is bound to be talent there, and as PSG has one of the best academies in France (If you’re about to contradict me, think about Nicolas Anelka, and that Liverpool has signed two of our youngsters in the last two years) so talent is sure to be developed.
Another thing I noted is that 80% of the Parisian players in our team are of African descent, and 90% of the Parisian academy graduates are of African descent. I have no idea what this says, but I thought it was interesting.
Note: Jerome Rothen is the sole Parisian player in the squad who did not attend the PSG academy.
This is the conclusion of part one of this post. I split it so I wouldn’t give you an information overload (like I haven’t already). I hope some of you were able to read this, because I certainly couldn’t If I was a PSG Offside reader.
Subscribe
|
Print
|
Share
![]() |
Comments | Add your comment
-



Grandi Ngoyi played for the French U21s this past FIFA date. I wouldn’t be surprised by the fact that most of the PSG academy graduates are African because Paris has a HUGE African community, especially in north Paris.
Posted from
United States

-



Oops. I was under the impression Ngoyi was playing in the Congo youth setup. My mistake. I’ll correct it.
Posted from
United States

-



Nice post. Can’t wait for part 2. I really apreciate the effort going into this blog. Not to be picky, but why didn’t you include Jeun-Eudes Maurice?
Posted from
United States

-



Rama: First of all thanks, but I didn’t include Maurice for two reasons. a) because he has never made a senior competitive appearance for the club and b) because information on him was very hard to come by.
Posted from
United States

-



Good post. Paris produces lot of footballers. Notable players from other clubs (even Marseille) are/were from Paris.
Posted from
United States

-



PSG’s academy was until very recently a very poor academy.
Not only did they miss on a lot of players (see Trezeguet) but they also let guys leave for nothing without seeing the talent (see Obertan).
With that said, in the next 5 years, PSG will produce plenty of very VERY good players.Posted from
United States

-



Evilo, Letting guys leave for nothing reflects more on poor management than the academy, doesn’t it? The academy is good as it developed the excellent players, it is the fault of people like Vahid Halilhodžić and Laurent Fournier who made the poor decisions regarding sales.
Posted from
United States

-



I disagree.
Obertan was never sold. He left because the PSG academy coaches didn’t believe in him.
Paris is the town outside Brazil that produces the most quality pros in the world.Yet how many internationals were products of the PSG academy?
Why do guys like Briand, Rothen, Gouffran, Bodmer, Henry and all these quality players always go to other academies?Posted from
United States

-



That’s a good point. However, at the moment, Players like Clement Chantome, Loris Arnaud, David N’Gog, Yannick Boli, Tripy Makonda, Jimmy Khamgain, etc. have come and are going through the academy. I feel that that signifies the current PSG academy as above average.
Posted from
United States

-



Also, the city of Paris is huge, do you really think PSG is going to be the first club to find all those players you mentioned? Because Paris produces so much talent, many clubs scout there, so PSG did not have a first option as you seem to suggest for many of these players, as other clubs could have gotten to them first if they were scouting the city.
Posted from
United States

-



Again, PSG has many future stars in its own club as 13-14 years old. They keep who they feel are the best ones, and they miss (see Diaby)!
They have the easiest way : young players are usually PSG fans themselves and they have the easiest scouting.
Yet they have failed to produce a star or at least international players for years.The League ranks the top academies every year. For the 3rd consecutive year, Rennes leads the way :
1. Stade Rennais FC : 4223 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
2. FC Girondins de Bordeaux : 2912 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
3. AS Monaco FC : 2904 points (catégorie 2, classe A)
4. FC Sochaux-Montbéliard : 2740,5 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
5. Toulouse FC : 2730 points (catégorie 2, classe A)
6. AS Saint-Etienne : 2613 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
7. Montpellier HSC : 2585 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
8. Olympique Lyonnais : 2477 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
9. Havre AC : 2445 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
10. FC Metz : 2354 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
11. AJ Auxerre : 2344,5 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
12. RC Strasbourg: 2342,5 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
13. FC Nantes : 2328 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
14. Paris Saint-Germain : 2302,5 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
15. LOSC Lille Métropole : 2296 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
16. Chamois Niortais : 2051 (Perte du statut pro)
17. ESTAC : 1662 (catégorie 2, classe A)
18. LB Châteauroux : 1644;5 points (catégorie 2, classe A)
19. RC Lens : 1634 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
20. AS Nancy Lorraine : 1594 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
21. Olympique de Marseille : 1437 points (catégorie 2, classe A)
22. SM Caen : 1270 points (catégorie 1, classe A)
23. SC Bastia : 1253 points (catégorie 2, classe A)
24. Le Mans UC 72 : 1209 points (catégorie 2, classe A)
25. EA Guingamp : 1143 points (catégorie 2, classe B*)
26. Amiens SC : 1122 points (catégorie 2, classe A)
27. OGC Nice : 1020 points (catégorie 2, classe A)
28. FC Lorient : 1014 points (catégorie 2, classe A)
29. Grenoble Foot 38 : 873,5 points (catégorie 2, classe B)
30. CS Sedan : 846 points (catégorie 2, classe B)
31. FC Gueugnon : 693 points (catégorie 2, classe B)
32. Stade de Reims : 40 points (catégorie 2, classe C)I don’t always agree with that ranking (I’d put Monaco higher) but that tells you something m PSG is nowhere to be seen. It’s ranked 14th. It is based on several factors :
- le nombre de contrats professionnels signés par les jeunes joueurs formés au club
- le nombre de matches joués en équipe première par les joueurs formés au club
- le nombre matches joués en sélection nationale par les joueurs formés au club
- le nombre de diplômes scolaires obtenus par les joueurs formés au club
- le statut des éducateursThe last time PSG won a Gambardella Cup (for U18 players) was 1991 and that was the only time they won it.
In comparison, Auxerre won it 6 times, Rennes won it twice in the last 6 years and a total of 3 wins, like Lyon, St Etienne, Nantes or Lens.The fact that didn’t even try to keep David N’Gog is also a huge testimony of how poor they manage youngsters.
That sends a really bad message all through the city to youngsters dreaming of playing for PSG (remember Badiane and so many others?) : PSG doesn’t need young players, as highly touted as they are (because N’Gog was highly touted).
Last but not least, when another highly touted player left PSG for Portsmouth (!), Gaël N’Lundulu said :
“Si le PSG avait voulu me garder, je serais resté”.To me, PSG has the easiest scouting and ability to sign youngsters compared to any pro club in L1. Yet their lack of trust in the youngsters, the mistakes in their scouting and the management mistakes has made them a poor academy.
WITH THAT SAID, they seem to slowly understand the importance of developping homegrown players and have paid more attention to their academy. However, their management still hasn’t evolved, since the N’Gog and N’Lundulu signings happenned a year ago (and both are WAY better than Arnaud or Boli who are L2 players most likely).Posted from
United States

-



Those are all very good points, but, I wouldn’t consider being ranked 14th “a very poor academy”. That’s ahead of clubs like Lille, Lens, Nancy, Marseille, Caen, Le Mans, Nice, Lorient, Grenoble, etc. Also, I believe that Arnaud and Boli will become good ligue 1 players, Boli will at least, he is only 20 after all.
Posted from
United States

-



Lille, Lens, Le Mans and Caen should be ranked better than PSG next year based on the number of games played by academy players.
Boli lacks talent, plain and simple.Posted from
United States

-



The number of games played by academy players does not necessarily indicate that the academy is stronger, it can also indicate that the rest of the team is weaker.
Posted from
United States

-



Take a look at the factors that I wrote up there.
And I’d take a Corchia (Le Mans), Hazard (Lille) or Monnet-Paquet (Lens) over a Arnaud or Boli.
Posted from
United States

-



That’s very true. What about over a Sakho though?
Posted from
United States

-



Sakho I like a lot obviously.
Only Hazard is a better prospect IMO.Posted from
United States

Leave a Reply
If you have not commented here before, please take a moment to peruse ourCommenting Guidelines.












